The Four Horsemen Of Nonbelief
Introduction
As a Hindu-turned-atheist-turned-agnostic, the most common question I have to answer, as you can most probably guess, is 'Why'? If only they appended an extra 'Why', then I could reply with 'Human Nature'; but alas, that is not to be. Regardless, in this case, the answer is much more interesting than its question.
Every time I am confronted with that question, I struggle to find an answer on the spot. Almost every nonbeliever has their own diverse reasons to be skeptical in the concept of religion, and I am no different. Yet, after much contemplation, research, and procrastination, I have arrived at a conclusion.
My reasons for disbelief can be boiled down to 4 separate arguments, or as I fancy calling them, 'The Four Horsemen Of Nonbelief'. These 'Four Horsemen' may resonate with other people such as myself, and they may not; these are but my own abstract results drawn from my own abstract thoughts.
So, let's get started, shall we?
1. The Pragmatic Argument
If you haven't heard of it, Pascal's Wager is a (deeply flawed) pragmatic argument to believe in god raised by Blaise Pascal, the renowned historical polymath. It states, in essence, that:
If there is a god, believers are rewarded, and nonbelievers are punished
If there is no god, there was no point anyway.
Pascal's logic is that, if we can never be sure if god really exists or not, the safest bet is to just believe. Now, there are multiple logical discrepancies in this argument, which I will not waste my time correcting. However, this framework of thought can be repurposed for our own agenda, and has unsurprisingly been done so before, in the Atheist's Wager.
However, the Atheist's Wager also contains some illogical assumptions, such as assuming that if a god exists, they are totally moral in the human sense. To remedy this, I had to formulate my own argument, or, as I like to call it, the Agnostic's Wager:
If there are any gods, and they are moral in the human sense, and you live a life as justly as you can within your situation, you will be rewarded.
If there are any gods, and they are immoral in the human sense, and you live a life as justly as you can within your situation, you will be punished, but at least you will not have served an evil deity.
If there are no gods, you lived a good life, and nothing was lost.
This new wager fills in the gaps in the Atheist's Wager, and forms the basis for the pragmatic argument against religion. After reading it, you may think, what does 'moral' or 'immoral' in the 'human sense' mean? Let me explain.
I define 'human' morality or immorality as anything that an unbiased human being would condone or condemn. For example, if a person was born in a tribalistic society, where pillaging and murder are normalized, and they did not have sufficient intellectual competence to realize the flaws of their existence, they would not exactly be innocent but would still be regarded as moral, by my definition, since they had no way of knowing that murder or hurting others is bad due to the broken system they were born in. Those who know that what they are doing is wrong, but still do it anyway, fall under immoral. Anyway, let's move on to the next argument.
2. The Logical Argument
Logical consistency is one of the most important aspects I seek in anything before I believe in it; but, alas, religion was not blessed with such awesome abilities as 'coherency' and 'uniformity'.
Let's assume that god is an omnibenevolent (all-loving), omnipotent (all-powerful) and omniscient (all-knowing) being, since most religions tend to preach that. Now, this opens up a whole new can of worms, which I will not dive too deep into, but I will look at the implications of it in religion. If god is truly all-knowing, then they obviously know about all the injustice in the world: slavery, murder, discrimination, and all that jazz. If god is truly all-loving, then they also care about these issues, and want to resolve them for good. If god is truly all-powerful, then they have the power to exterminate these issues and the possibility of them ever happening again, for good.
But that's the thing; god doesn't do that. If god can't stop evil, they are not omnipotent. If they don't know about evil, they are not omniscient. If they don't care about evil or want it to happen, they are not omnibenevolent. And if they are neither knowing, loving, nor powerful, why call them god? This is called the problem of evil, and it has been keeping up religious people at night for over a millennium. Consequently, they have found some primitive refutes, which I shall debunk.
Many apologists claim that the existence of evil is necessary because we were given free will, which allows us to do whatever we want. All well and good, except that all evil is not caused by humans; natural disasters, terminal illnesses in children, etc. still exist and have existed throughout history and beyond. These are not caused by any humans, yet god seems to allow them, for no apparent reason. Another group argues that there is more glory in god defeating evil than there is in not having it at all, which is a psychopathic worldview. If god is omnipotent, they can find glory by other means; if they are omnibenevolent, they would not put humans through suffering at any cost.
3. The Scientific Argument
Now that we are done with the pragmatics and logical intricacies of religion, let us poke at, what is undeniably, the most important aspect of any authoritative text - scientific accuracy. Before you get excited, let me tell you: not a single mainstream religion is scientifically accurate. Note that a good chunk of this section relies on rendering concepts unfalsifiable to render them meaningless. But, what does it mean for a concept to be unfalsifiable, you say? A concept is unfalsifiable if it literally cannot be disproven or contradicted in any way, shape, or form. A popular example is Last-Thursdayism. If I say that the universe began last Thursday, and everything was created in its current form exactly on that day, memories already implanted, soil already eroded, etc. could you refute it? No. But is it meaningful at all? No to that, too. These concepts also fall into that category, one way or the other.
Let's start with Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, since they have some overlapping concepts. Samsara is the concept that humans are in an infinite cycle of birth, death, and rebirth. Karma is the concept that the injustices or justices you do to others will be 'repaid' to you by the injustices or justices of others done to you. If you rack up enough good Karma, then you achieve Moksha or Nirvana, which is freedom from Samsara. Samsara can be made meaningless by two arguments: that the human brain physically loses all its biological circuitry on death, rendering retrieval of that information impossible for any purpose by anything, or, that since we can never know whether the person was rebirthed or not, it is unfalsifiable. Either works for our purposes. Moksha is also unfalsifiable in this very way. Karma could be physically disproven, since many evil people get away with their horrific acts, but it also relies on the 'payback' happening in the next birth - again, unfalsifiable.
Now for the Abrahamic family! Christianity famously contains Noah's Ark, when god had the bright idea to kill every living being on Earth by raising the oceans to the largest mountains, and making a guy build a boat that contains two of every animal. Now, first of all, there is physically not enough water in the Earth to go up to the peaks of Mount Everest. Secondly, two of each animal is way too low a number for an entire population to revive itself. Thirdly, a boat large enough to contain every animal in its comfortable habitat would need to be as large as a continent, since animals are not just compressed packages; they are living, breathing beings that need quite a large space to themselves, in their native environments, to not develop zoochosis. Not to even mention the sheer quantity of food the animals would need, and the truly massive amount of shi—I mean, feces—that they would generate.
The Quran also doesn't get away with its scientific impossibilities. It states that mountains are like pegs or stakes on the Earth placed so that the Earth should not shake. Obviously, this is because the authors of the Quran thought the Earth was flat, as was the general consensus in the Middle East in the Early Islamic Era, when the Quran was composed. This is also made more obvious by the fact that it doesn't seem to understand how the rotation or revolution of the Earth works; it claims that the Moon and Sun orbit the earth in tandem, even though that could not be further from the truth. Now, to the credit of Islam, almost every religion claims or implies in its 'holy' texts that the Earth is flat, but it also raises an interesting question as to how or why an all-knowing god would commit such a folly, and not correct the original authors.
4. The Political Argument
The things we believe in have an almost uncanny control over how we view what is wrong, what is right, and how things should be. And religion has a (mostly) dormant, almost unprecedented power to take control of our lives in the worst way possible, via the form of a theocracy. This is exactly why Separation of Church and State laws exist; to prevent religion from seeping into the entrails of a government.
Religions request unfettered loyalty and devotion from followers. If they were woven into the state, the consequences would be unimaginably horrific. A corrupt dictator could bend their people to the knees, exploit them and others of every right and resource, and still be celebrated, in the name of god. Because, disloyalty to the ruler can be very easily masqueraded as disloyalty to god. If a government ever makes itself second to god, the people will have already lost, because you cannot fight a system that defines itself as divine.
We have already seen this in action, in the world's current theocracies. Iran is a horrific place to live in now, because of the current Islamic 'revolution'; people are stripped of basic human rights, including freedom of speech, freedom to wear any clothing you want, and, importantly, freedom of religion, or lack thereof. Afghanistan explicitly makes every person wear a burka, the traditional garment of Islam, whether they want it or not, under the universally unrecognized, unlawful rule of the radical Islamic group, the Taliban.
We are already seeing specks of this corruption evolve in other governments, too. The Jewish Nationalist people of Israel refuse to see that they are committing a genocide in Palestine; the current Christian Nationalist administration in America has explicitly shunned atheists as 'communists' on its own websites recently, and has systematically been taking away the rights of minorities since its debut in 2025; the current Hindu Nationalist government in India has actively been trying to blur the lines between religion and government, and all of them for what is undoubtedly their own gain of power.
The recent resurgence of 'traditionalism' is also not a good sign, at all. Romanticizing an idealized past has been used by many authoritarian states to quench protests from its people, by fostering a false sense of ancient unity or ethnic bonding. By tricking its people with fantasies of the past, a regime can make its people sacrifice their autonomy for an impossible fiction. This tactic was historically utilized by the Nazi regime, and if you look closely at any nationalist government in the world, you will see this 'mark of the beast', or so to say, everywhere; and once you see it, you cannot unsee it. And religion is a particularly strong poison in this regard, which is why religious nationalist governments are oftentimes the most successful in maintaining this perfect image of 'tradition'.
Conclusion
Now, most readers who read this article will probably fall into two boxes: one group will vehemently agree, and another will vehemently disagree. This article is not an attack on religion, though I managed to do that very well, didn't I? As religion is being integrated more and more into our societies after a relatively long period of peace, it is infiltrating aggressively. Other worldviews which are not understood or even thought of are being terminated one by one. Minorities, and even some majorities, are yet again losing any level of positive inclusion which might have been fostered in recent years. This article is my angry, ruthless rebellion against the pattern of recent years. It is my personal little thoughtcrime against the trend of the world slowly becoming 1984.